18 American Candy Bars We Can’t Find on Shelves Anymore, But Still Love

Nothing sparks nostalgia quite like the taste of a favorite childhood candy bar. Though time has marched on, some of the sweetest treats from decades past live on in our memories, even if they’ve disappeared from store shelves.

Whether it was a peanut-packed indulgence, a caramel-infused delight, or a crunchy, chocolate-covered masterpiece, these bars were more than just snacks—they were part of our history.

So let’s remember the candy bars that may be gone but are certainly not forgotten.

1. Hershey’s Bar None

For chocolate lovers, Hershey’s Bar None was a dream come true when it debuted in 1987. This decadent bar combined layers of crispy chocolate wafers, rich chocolate cream, and peanuts, all wrapped in a velvety chocolate coating. It was a triple threat of flavor, texture, and indulgence.

Despite its devoted fan base, Bar None vanished from shelves in 1997. Some blame shifting consumer preferences, while others believe it was simply overshadowed by bigger brands. Whatever the reason, this chocolatey masterpiece left a void that candy lovers still feel today.

2. PB Max

Peanut butter lovers rejoiced when PB Max hit the market in the early ‘90s. With its creamy peanut butter filling, crunchy oats, and thick chocolate coating, it delivered a sweet and salty flavor explosion. Many saw it as a competitor to Reese’s, and for a while, it held its own.

However, PB Max didn’t last long. Rumor has it that the Mars family—who owned the brand—simply weren’t fans of peanut butter and pulled the plug on the product, despite its success. Fans still fondly recall the unique taste and wish for its return.

3. Butterfinger BB’s

Butterfinger BB’s took everything great about the classic Butterfinger bar and made it bite-sized. Launched in 1992, these crunchy little spheres coated in peanut butter and chocolate were an instant hit, especially among kids and teens.

Though beloved, they were discontinued in 2006, reportedly due to challenges in production and packaging. Many still remember them fondly, not just for their taste but for their unforgettable commercials featuring Bart Simpson, who famously told us to “nobody lay a finger on my Butterfinger.”

4. Reggie! Bar

This candy bar was more than just a sweet treat—it was a tribute to baseball legend Reggie Jackson. Introduced in 1978, the chewy caramel and peanut-filled chocolate bar became an instant fan favorite among Yankees supporters and candy lovers alike.

However, when Jackson left New York, the bar’s popularity took a nosedive, and production ceased by 1981. While short-lived, it remains a cherished relic of baseball history, proving that sometimes, candy bars and sports can go hand in hand.

5. Seven Up Bar

No, this candy bar had nothing to do with the lemon-lime soda! The Seven Up Bar was a truly unique creation, featuring seven different flavored sections all in one chocolate bar—everything from coconut to mint to caramel.

Introduced in the 1930s, it had a good run but was discontinued in the 1970s due to rising production costs and changing consumer tastes.

Still, its variety-packed concept remains legendary, and those who got to experience it often say no other candy bar has ever compared.

6. Marathon Bar

Candy bars are usually known for their flavors, but the Marathon Bar stood out for its shape. Introduced in 1973, this twisted, braided caramel bar covered in chocolate was incredibly long, even coming with a built-in ruler on the wrapper to emphasize its size.

Despite its novelty, the Marathon Bar was discontinued in 1981, likely due to its complex production process. While some claim Cadbury’s Curly Wurly is a close cousin, Marathon fans still insist that nothing has ever truly replaced it.

7. Milkshake Bar

Long before fancy chocolate milkshakes became a dessert trend, the Milkshake Bar delivered that same creamy experience in candy form. Launched in the 1920s, this nougat-filled delight was designed to mimic the rich flavor of a malted milkshake, covered in smooth chocolate.

It remained popular for decades but was phased out in the early 1980s, likely due to stiff competition from bigger brands. Those who had the pleasure of tasting it say no modern candy bar has captured its signature milkshake-like flavor.

8. Summit Bar

Summit Bars made their debut in the mid-1970s, offering a delicious mix of peanuts, chocolate, and a crispy cookie center. If you loved a candy bar with layers of crunch and nuttiness, this was the ultimate treat.

However, the Summit Bar quietly disappeared by the late ‘70s, likely because it was overshadowed by bigger candy brands. Even so, those who were lucky enough to try it still rave about its perfect balance of flavors.

9. Space Food Sticks

These weren’t just any candy bars—they were designed for astronauts! Inspired by the space race of the 1960s, Space Food Sticks were chewy, nutrient-packed snacks originally created for NASA but later sold to the public as a futuristic treat.

While they were a novelty at first, they faded from shelves by the late 1970s, as public interest in space snacks declined. Still, they remain a cool relic of an era when everything—including candy—was reaching for the stars.

10. Whatchamacallit

Whatchamacallit is one of the few candy bars on this list that still exists today—but the version we have now isn’t quite the same as the original. When Hershey’s introduced it in 1978, it featured a delicious mix of peanut-flavored crisp, caramel, and a rich chocolate coating.

Over the years, the recipe has changed, and many fans argue that the original formula was far superior.

The catchy commercial jingles and whimsical name helped cement its place in candy history, but for those who loved the classic taste, the modern version just isn’t quite the same.

11. Nestlé’s Triple Decker Bar

For chocolate lovers, Nestlé’s Triple Decker Bar was a dream come true. This candy bar featured three layers of chocolate—milk, dark, and white—stacked together in one delicious bite. It was a chocolate trifecta that offered something for everyone.

Despite its unique appeal, this multi-layered delight was discontinued in the late 1960s, likely due to shifting consumer preferences and production costs.

Those who had the chance to experience it still reminisce about its rich, varied flavors, wishing they could enjoy just one more bite.

12. Bun Candy Bar

With a name as simple as “Bun,” you might not expect much, but this nut-filled, caramel-packed treat had a loyal following for decades. Originally introduced in the 1920s, the Bun Bar came in multiple flavors, including vanilla, maple, and caramel, all covered in chocolate and peanuts.

Despite its long history, it eventually disappeared from mainstream candy aisles in the late 1970s. While a version of it still exists in some specialty candy shops, its widespread availability is a thing of the past, leaving longtime fans nostalgic for the sweet, nutty goodness they once loved.

13. Forever Yours

Before Milky Way Dark, there was Forever Yours—a rich, indulgent candy bar with a dark chocolate coating, nougat, and caramel. First introduced in the 1930s, this treat was a favorite among those who preferred a bolder, less sweet chocolate experience.

However, in 1989, Mars decided to rebrand it as Milky Way Dark, eventually phasing out the original Forever Yours name. While the rebranded version remains, longtime fans insist that the original just had something special that can’t quite be replicated.

14. Caravelle Bar

For those who love the mix of crunchy textures and sweet, gooey caramel, the Caravelle Bar was a hidden gem of the 1970s. It combined crispy rice, smooth caramel, and milk chocolate into a candy bar that rivaled its competitors.

Unfortunately, despite its devoted following, the Caravelle Bar disappeared from shelves in the 1980s. Fans still rave about its perfect blend of crunch and chewiness, lamenting that no current candy bar has managed to capture its unique charm.

15. Nestlé Alpine White

White chocolate lovers still long for the return of Nestlé Alpine White, a sophisticated candy bar from the 1980s that paired creamy white chocolate with crunchy almonds. Its elegant packaging and unique flavor set it apart in a market dominated by milk and dark chocolate.

Sadly, this creamy confection was discontinued in the early 1990s, likely due to changes in consumer trends and competition. However, those who enjoyed its smooth, nutty taste still remember it fondly as a rare treat that stood out in the candy aisle.

16. Velamints

More than just a candy, Velamints were the minty breath fresheners that made you feel fancy. Launched in the 1980s, these sleek, European-style mints came in elegant tins and were marketed as a chic alternative to traditional mints.

Despite their popularity, Velamints eventually faded away due to market competition and changing ownership. Though some variations have been brought back over the years, many fans argue that the original formula had a distinct flavor that’s never been fully replicated.

17. Choco’Lite

For chocolate fans who preferred a light, airy texture, Choco’Lite was the ultimate treat. Introduced in the 1970s, this bubbly chocolate bar was known for its unique aerated structure, giving it a melt-in-your-mouth experience.

Unfortunately, Choco’Lite disappeared from store shelves in the 1980s, possibly due to low sales and a crowded chocolate bar market. While some compare it to today’s Aero Bar, loyal fans insist that nothing quite compares to the original.

18. PowerHouse

True to its name, PowerHouse was a hefty, satisfying candy bar packed with caramel, peanuts, and fudge. Originally introduced in the 1950s, it was a favorite among those looking for a rich, filling treat that delivered on both flavor and texture.

Despite its popularity, PowerHouse was discontinued in the 1970s, likely due to rising competition from other peanut-and-caramel candy bars like Snickers. Still, those who remember it describe it as a true classic that deserved a much longer run.